Thursday, October 18, 2012

A Sokal-Like Hoax in the Field of Mathematics

Some people in the hard sciences can be hoodwinked as well. See



Paul Taylor, Stochastically Orthogonal (October 17, 2012) (blog post)


Extract:

When Alan Sokal tricked Social Text into publishing a nonsensical parody of postmodernist criticism, he thought the journal’s failure to spot that the article was a hoax revealed a shocking lack of intellectual rigour. John Sturrock, writing about it in the LRB, noted that Social Text exists in a different realm of discourse from Nature and that Sokal’s contribution, for all its faults, was a ‘jauntily expressed’ piece of ‘extreme provocation’, and as Sokal knew, the kind of thing that Social Text existed to promote. Well yes, but, as legions of letter writers responded, don’t things you publish sort of have to make sense?
Last month That’s Mathematics! reported another landmark event in the history of academic publishing. A paper by Marcie Rathke of the University of Southern North Dakota at Hoople had been provisionally accepted for publication in Advances in Pure Mathematics. ‘Independent, Negative, Canonically Turing Arrows of Equations and Problems in Applied Formal PDE’ concludes:
Now unfortunately, we cannot assume that










It is difficult, as a non-specialist, to judge the weight of that ‘unfortunately’. 

[END OF QUOTATION]

Hint by Tillers: The equations and expressions found above are gibberish.
Post a Comment